Friday, 24 April 2015

LED vs incandescent

One of the effects I've noticed is that LED light sources seem to give a crisper shadow than Incandescent light sources.

Incandescent light

LED light


I can't quite work out why this might be the case. It might be related to how the light is created by LEDs or perhaps it is polarized or something affects our perception?

Incandescent lights emit a full spectrum emmission. Electricity is passed through a (usually) tungsten filament that heats up and emits electromagnetic radiation in the visible spectrum.

LED lights, on the other hand, release light via electroluminescence where a photon of light is released. The colour of the light depends on the energy of the photon. Consequently LEDs emit light within a specific part of the electromagnetic spectrum.

A comparison between the spectra from various sources shows that incandescent light is strongly skewed towards the red end of the spectrum while (white) LED light has a peak in the blue spectrum and a peak in the green spectrum tailing off into the red. This pattern more closely resembles the spectrum of daylight.


There are also several ways that LEDs are combined to produce white light.
Phosphor Conversion uses a blue gallium nitride diode to excite a yellow emitting phosphor coating. This produces a mix of blue and yellow light that mixes to create white. This method is the most common and is likely the type of lighting used in the LEDs we have to hand.
Othe methods include Colour Mixed LEDs where the proper amount of light from Red, Green and Blue (RGB) LEDs yields white light.
A third method is a hybrid that uses both a phosphor coating and discrete monochromatic LEDs.

Apparently the level of blue light in the LED spectrum causes the pupil opening of the eye to become smaller and increase visual acuity. So, maybe just using the blue-ish LED lights makes the shadow appear sharper - except that it is captured on film! A camera doesn't have a pupil to dilate so that can't be the source.

I initially thought that the light may be polarized but passing a polarizing filter over LED light appears to reduce the glare of an LED light it suggests that the light is unpolarized to begin with. 

This suggests to me that it may be something to do with wavelength. Blue light is radiated at a wavelength of 450-495nm whereas yellow light is emmitted at 570-590nm. This goes back to a previous post regarding single-slit diffraction.

The single-slit experiment was developed based on the observation that light diffracts around the edges of objects. Blue light will diffract less than red light  because the wavelength is shorter. Longer wavelengths are redirected more strongly than shorter wavelengths.

At least that's the argument I'm going with - it's based on Huygens Principle but that is a mathematical model of reality and there are competing models such as Quantum Theory that may also explain it. A simple question gets very deep and philosophical very quickly.

For my purposes LEDs make sharper shadows! 

1 comment:

  1. It's due to LEDs being a small point light source typically only 1mm across compared to incandescent lighting which might have a filament 10mm long. IF you directly photograph the light source with a heavy neutral filter you'll be able to see it's shape.

    ReplyDelete